Which humidifier is
right for you?
Answer 6 quick questions to find out whether a steam, evaporative, hybrid or ultrasonic humidifier (加湿器, kashitsuki) fits your room, plus the monthly electricity cost including heating.
Why it fits
Watch out for
What would the other types cost?
| Type | Per liter of water | Per month |
|---|
Share your result
How the quiz works: 4 types and how you get one
Each of your 6 answers adds points to the 4 humidifier types, and the type with the most points is your result (ties go in this order: hybrid, steam, evaporative, ultrasonic). Your cost is calculated from your heating (question 1) and hours of use (question 3).
The 6 questions
- What mainly heats the room? (air conditioner / electric heater / gas or kerosene heater, floor heating / hardly any)
- How big is the room? (up to 8 mats / 9–14 / 15 or more; 1 mat ≈ 1.6 m²)
- How long will you run it each day? (up to about 3 hours / 3–8 hours / 8 hours or more)
- How much cleaning can you handle? (as little as possible / a filter once a week / water and washing daily)
- Do you have small kids or pets?
- What matters most to you? (low electricity cost / strong, fast humidifying / a small, quiet unit)
Cost per liter of water
| Type | Unit's electricity the makers' method | Air-conditioned room incl. heating, estimate | Electric heater room incl. heating, estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam | about ¥26.5 | about ¥24.3 | about ¥21.1 |
| Hybrid (eco) | about ¥1.9 | about ¥9.6 | about ¥21.1 |
| Evaporative | about ¥0.6 | about ¥8.8 | about ¥21.1 |
| Ultrasonic | about ¥2.4 | about ¥9.9 | about ¥21.1 |
The unit's electricity uses the same method as the makers (Panasonic, Sharp and others): power use × unit price. "Including heating" is our own estimate: evaporating water takes heat from the room (about 0.68 kWh per liter), and we add what your heating spends to replace it. Makers don't calculate it this way. The air conditioner efficiency of 2.5× is its value at 2°C outside in Daikin's catalog (S226ATES 2.8 kW ÷ 1,130 W; about 4.7× at 7°C), and we assume it holds even at low output (not measured). Electricity at ¥31/kWh. Models are in the notes at the bottom of the page.
How often each type comes up
There are 648 possible combinations of answers. Counting each one once: hybrid 34.9%, evaporative 27.6%, ultrasonic 19.6%, steam 17.9%.
These shares count every combination equally. They are not the share of people who took the quiz.
About this humidifier quiz
Q. What is the difference between the four types?
A. Steam boils water, evaporative blows air through a wet filter, hybrid combines heat with evaporation, and ultrasonic makes mist with vibrations.
Steam is hygienic but uses more electricity; evaporative saves energy but humidifies more slowly; hybrid offers more features; ultrasonic is inexpensive but needs frequent cleaning.
Q. Which suits a room with babies or pets?
A. Evaporative or hybrid.
A steam humidifier's outlet gets hot.