日本語
Compare | Updated October 2026

Hot-water bottle or electric foot warmer:
which costs less?

Ms. Hakari, the scales

The short version…

  • On electricity alone, the electric foot warmer wins: about ¥0.1 for 30 minutes before bed
  • Boiling 2 L of water in an electric kettle for a hot-water bottle costs about ¥6.7
  • Take either one out once the bed is warm, to avoid low-temperature burns
Calculate a winter's cost ↓

Cost per night and surface temperature

Item30 min before bedAll night (8 h)Surface temperature
Hot-water bottle
2 L of hot water
Boiling it in a kettle ~¥6.7 (however long you use it)Depends on the water
Electric foot warmer (flat)
Koden VWH601H (60 W)
High ~¥0.1Low ~¥0.1 / high ~¥1.4High ~60°C / med ~45°C / low ~30°C
Electric foot warmer (dome)
Koden VWY601H (60 W)
High ~¥0.1Low ~¥0.2 / high ~¥2.1High ~60°C / med ~45°C / low ~30°C
Electric blanket
Koden CWB551 series (55 W)
High ~¥0.5Medium ~¥4.5High ~52°C / med ~36°C

← Scroll sideways →

Foot warmers and electric blanket: from the maker's published energy per hour (flat: high 5.5 / medium 3.2 / low 0.5 Wh; dome: high 8.6 / medium 4.1 / low 0.9 Wh; blanket: high 31 / medium 18 Wh). Hot-water bottle: T-fal's published measurement (Justine Plus Lock 1.0L electric kettle, water at 23°C boiled until it switches off: about ¥3.35 per liter at ¥31/kWh), doubled for 2 L. A kettle always boils the water, so the temperature you fill at doesn't change the cost. In winter the water is colder, so it costs a little more.

Professor PlugProfessor Plug
A foot warmer may say "60 W", but once warm it cuts back, using only 5.5 Wh an hour even on high. Warming something small is cheap.

Winter cost by how you use it

Pick an item and how you use it.

2.0 L
Per night¥6.7
Per month (30 days)¥201
Winter (120 days)¥804

Take the hot-water bottle out once the bed is warm (Consumer Affairs Agency).

Winter is December to March, about 120 days. Hot-water bottle: boiled in an electric kettle (from T-fal's measurement). Foot warmer: Koden VWH601H; electric blanket: Koden CWB551 series, published figures.

Note: electricity on this page is priced at a flat ¥31/kWh nationwide (National Fair Trade Council guideline).

Want the details? (tap to open)

Low-temperature burns: temperature × time

Even pleasant warmth can burn if it stays on one spot

A low-temperature burn can happen at a pleasantly warm temperature if the same patch of skin stays in contact for long. The Consumer Affairs Agency gives these guides: 3–4 hours at 44°C, 30 minutes to 1 hour at 46°C, 2–3 minutes at 50°C.

Time in contact until a low-temperature burn (guide) 44°C3–4 hours 46°C30 min – 1 hour 50°C2–3 minutes Foot warmer surface: high ~60°C, medium ~45°C (Koden). Electric blanket: high ~52°C.

← Scroll sideways →

The Consumer Affairs Agency received 363 reports of hot-water bottle accidents from September 2009 to October 2017, 240 of them burns. Of 108 reports from November 2015 to October 2020, 31 were serious burns taking more than a month to heal. Some people were burned even with a cover on.

Don't: fall asleep with a hot-water bottle or foot warmer in the bed
Instead: take it out or switch it off once the bed is warm (Consumer Affairs Agency, Tokyo). For warmth all night, use an electric blanket on a low setting

Cautions by type of hot-water bottle

Hot-water, microwave and rechargeable types each need different care
TypeCautions
Fill with hot waterDon't use with too little water (metal or hard plastic). For types you can heat on a flame or IH hob, always remove the cap first
MicrowaveFollow the stated power and time. Don't use auto or "leave it to me" modes
Rechargeable (electric heat storage)Don't charge it under bedding or a cover. Don't use it while charging

Source: Consumer Affairs Agency. Whatever the type, check for cracks or tears before use, and check whether it's subject to a recall.

Which one?

Before bed only, power cuts, or all night
Warm bed, then sleep: an electric foot warmer. Heat the bed on high and take it out when you get in. The electricity cost is almost nothing
No electricity, ready for power cuts: a fill-with-water hot-water bottle. You have to boil water, but there's no plug
Warm all night: not a foot warmer or hot-water bottle. Use an electric blanket on a low setting. Warm it on high before bed, then turn it down

Good to know if you live in Japan

Japanese search terms, and more
  1. Search in Japanese

    Hot-water bottle is 湯たんぽ (yutanpo). Electric foot warmer is 電気あんか (denki anka). Rechargeable types are 充電式湯たんぽ or 蓄熱式湯たんぽ; microwave types are レンジ湯たんぽ.
  2. Look for the PSE mark on electric foot warmers

    Household power here is 100V. Electric foot warmers (電気あんか) are covered by Japan's electrical safety law, so buy one made for Japan with the PSE mark. For rechargeable hot-water bottles, follow the maker's charging instructions.
  3. Your electricity rate may differ

    We use ¥31/kWh, the industry guideline. Your actual rate depends on your plan and power company.

FAQ

Is it cheaper to boil the water with gas?
Gas prices vary a lot by region and plan, so we only calculate for electricity here. Either way, the heat needed to bring 2 L to 80°C (about 0.15 kWh) is the same.
Can I keep a hot-water bottle in bed all night if I wrap it in a towel?
No. Tokyo has reports of a towel slipping off and the bottle causing a low-temperature burn, and the Consumer Affairs Agency describes burns even with a cover on. Take it out once the bed is warm.
What about older family members?
People who feel heat less or turn over less in their sleep are less likely to notice a low-temperature burn. Agree as a family to warm the bed and then take the warmer out.
Which costs less per use?
A. The electric foot warmer.
About ¥0.1 for 30 minutes before bed. A hot-water bottle costs about ¥6.7 to boil 2 L of water in an electric kettle.
How big is the difference over a winter (120 days)?
A. About ¥790.
With the water boiled in an electric kettle (from T-fal's measurement).
How do they differ in effort and safety?
A. The foot warmer just plugs in; the hot-water bottle needs water boiled and poured each time.
A hot-water bottle uses no electricity, so it works where there is no outlet.
Can I leave it in the futon while I sleep?
A. Take it out of the futon before you sleep.
The Consumer Affairs Agency and the Tokyo Metropolitan Government warn about low-temperature burns.
Hodoyo-kun

Which heater is right for you?
Answer 7 questions and find the heater that's just right for you.

Take the heater quiz

Related guides